Question
Aktualisiert am
3 Mai 2021
- Koreanisch Fast fließend
-
Englisch (US)
Frage über Englisch (US)
I have a question for native English speakers.
In Korean grammar, the verb -have- is classified into two types: auxiliary verbs and verbs.
When used like -have + past participle-, it is called a modal verb.
When written like -have + something-, it is called a verb.
Do native speakers feel -have- as a different category of verb in each case?
Or do you feel that have has only one meaning and only the object is different?
I have a question for native English speakers.
In Korean grammar, the verb -have- is classified into two types: auxiliary verbs and verbs.
When used like -have + past participle-, it is called a modal verb.
When written like -have + something-, it is called a verb.
Do native speakers feel -have- as a different category of verb in each case?
Or do you feel that have has only one meaning and only the object is different?
In Korean grammar, the verb -have- is classified into two types: auxiliary verbs and verbs.
When used like -have + past participle-, it is called a modal verb.
When written like -have + something-, it is called a verb.
Do native speakers feel -have- as a different category of verb in each case?
Or do you feel that have has only one meaning and only the object is different?
Antworten
Wenn du eine Antwort mit "Gefällt mir nicht" markierst
Wird der Besitzer der Frage nicht benachrichtigt.
Nur der Nutzer, der die Frage gestellt hat, kann sehen wer damit nicht einverstanden war.
3 Mai 2021
Favorisierte Antwort
- Englisch (US)
We feel like they are different. “Have” as an auxiliary verb does not have the same meaning as the regular verb “have.”
As an auxiliary verb, “have” has almost no meaning besides “in the past,” it is just used for the grammar, and the 2nd verb has all the important meaning.
As a verb, “have” has all the important meaning.
Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung
War diese Antwort hilfreich?
Offensichtlich falsch
Die Erklärung ist nicht ausreichend
In einer Sprache geschrieben, die ich nicht verstehe
Die Antwort hat nichts mit der Frage zu tun
Anderer Grund
Mehr Kommentare lesen
- Englisch (US)
We feel like they are different. “Have” as an auxiliary verb does not have the same meaning as the regular verb “have.”
As an auxiliary verb, “have” has almost no meaning besides “in the past,” it is just used for the grammar, and the 2nd verb has all the important meaning.
As a verb, “have” has all the important meaning.
Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung
War diese Antwort hilfreich?
- Koreanisch Fast fließend
@3chord Thank you for the answer!
May I ask you an additional question?
Are your answers based on grammatical knowledge?
Or is it based on your everyday sense of language?
The reason I ask this question is that, in fact, few Koreans have a deep knowledge of the grammar of their native language. Usually, they rely on the instinctive sense of language that they have learned from childhood.
Could I judge that your answer is a everyday and instinctive sense of language most people have?
May I ask you an additional question?
Are your answers based on grammatical knowledge?
Or is it based on your everyday sense of language?
The reason I ask this question is that, in fact, few Koreans have a deep knowledge of the grammar of their native language. Usually, they rely on the instinctive sense of language that they have learned from childhood.
Could I judge that your answer is a everyday and instinctive sense of language most people have?
- Englisch (US)
@youyou88 My answers are based on instinctive sense of the language. In American schools, children learn about spelling, but most of us do not learn anything about grammar. We learn all of it by reading and listening to the words of other people. Because of this, most Americans do not use “perfect” grammar, and we do not know basic grammar terms.
For example, I asked some of my friends about “have” as an auxiliary verb, and they did not know what an “auxiliary verb” means. They were not sure if it has one meaning or two meanings. But they all use the word correctly.
Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung
War diese Antwort hilfreich?
[Neuigkeiten] Hallo du! Die/derjenige, die/der eine Sprache lernt!
Möchten Sie wissen, wie Sie Ihre Sprachkenntnisse verbessern können❓ Alles, was Sie tun müssen, ist, Ihre Schreiben durch einen Muttersprachler korrigieren zu lassen!
Mit HiNative können Sie Ihre Schreiben kostenlos durch Muttersprachler korrigieren lassen ✍️✨.
Mit HiNative können Sie Ihre Schreiben kostenlos durch Muttersprachler korrigieren lassen ✍️✨.
Registrieren
Ähnliche Fragen
Ähnliche Fragen
- Which is more natural? Can I ask a question? Or can I ask you a question?
- I have a little question about linguistic. That is what is Xbar theory? What functions does it h...
- I have a question regarding the following sentence. "I aimed my remarks at Susan, but she did...
Trending questions
- How do you say "2m x 1m" in English? ex. I would like to buy a small rectangle area rug 2m x 1m.
- What did the bride say at 0:05 -? "It's just xxxxx I guess" https://youtu.be/fKDbr483TKc?si=aI7s...
- 📍Do these have the same meaning and sound natural? The perception of how the word sounds like wo...
- (at an ESL class) "Please check your answers against your partner's ones." Hello! Do you thin...
- These revisions maintain the same meaning while providing a smoother flow to the sentences. Is t...
Newest Questions (HOT)
- Ich habe in einem Deutschbuch gelesen: Ich mag Heidelberg, weil sie eine wunderschöne Stadt ist!...
- Wie liest man diesen Zahl? 0,5 Prozent
- klingt das natürlich? " Ich bin auch für dich gespannt 🙏🏻 Gestern habe ich gedacht dass ich di...
- klingt das natürlich? Entschuldigung, wo ist des Zimmers Herr Doktor Müller?
- Können Sie bitte korrigieren? 1. Wenn ich fleßiger wäre, würde ich Russisch studieren. 2. Möcht...
Newest Questions
- Give me some common texting abbreviations/slang like “ lol, idk “ etc . Thank you !
- Ist dieser Satz natürlich? Wanst sein meir Huhn oder Fisch? "Do you want more chicken or fish?"
- Ist das Gespräch natürlich? 1. A: What can I do for you today? 2. B: I need to mail this pack...
- Could you tell me how to use "an", "in" and "auf". Feel free to provide some examples. Danke.
- Heute möchte ich über ein sehr wichtiges Thema schreiben, das Momentan sehr häufig diskutiert wir...
Vorherige Frage/ Nächste Frage
Was ist dieses Symbol?
Das Sprachstufen-Symbol zeigt deine Fähigkeiten in einer Sprache, an der du interessiert bist. Festlegen deiner Sprachstufe hilft Benutzern, einfach verständliche Antworten zu schreiben.
-
Anfänger
Hat Schwierigkeiten, selbst kurze Anworten in dieser Sprache zu verstehen.
-
Anfänger (intermediär)
Kann einfache Sätze bilden und einfache Fragen verstehen.
-
Fortgeschrittener Anfänger
Kann jede Art von allgemeinen Fragen stellen und lange Antworten verstehen.
-
Fortgeschritten
Fähig lange, komplexe Antworten zu verstehen.
Melde dich für Premium an, um Audio-/Videoantworten anderer Nutzer abspielen zu können.
Was sind Geschenke?
Show your appreciation in a way that likes and stamps can't.
By sending a gift to someone, they will be more likely to answer your questions again!
If you post a question after sending a gift to someone, your question will be displayed in a special section on that person’s feed.
Sie sind das Suchen leid? HiNative kann Ihnen helfen, die Antwort zu finden, nach der Sie suchen.
Danke! Sei versichert, dass dein Feedback den anderen Benutzern nicht angezeigt wird.
Vielen Dank! Dein Feedback wird sehr geschätzt.
