Was ist der Unterschied zwischen “Did you see that?” und “Have you seen that?” (When you show something that has just happened) ?Du kannst auch einfach Beispielsätze geben.

Antworten

RaquelM67

9 Okt 2021

Englisch (US)

Did you see that lady just now? Did you see that article in the paper?
Have you seen the new Disney movie? Have you seen that video by the Stray Kids?

Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

sattiiiii

9 Okt 2021

Russisch

@RaquelM67 thanks! I thought that “did you see” can be only used referring to the past. Not to “just now”.. it’s interesting

RaquelM67

9 Okt 2021

Englisch (US)

It 's confusing too, right? English is pretty wonky sometimes.

Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

sattiiiii

10 Okt 2021

Russisch

@RaquelM67 my son (3y.o.) says to me all the time: „Mama, did you see that?!“ when he makes anything. So should I answer „I saw it/that!“ instead of „I have seen that!“?

(We speak English at home. But I am Russian and my husband is Brazilian! Our son is studying English a lot watching cartoons and Blippi on YouTube. Looks like he knows it better than me lol)

RaquelM67

10 Okt 2021

Englisch (US)

Yes, answer "I saw it/that". Nice to have him learn so young! I wish I did.

Antwortender mit hoher Bewertung

War diese Antwort hilfreich?

sattiiiii

11 Okt 2021

Russisch

@RaquelM67 he can also say “I’m so excited to brush teeth! Let’s go now“ after 1 hour of my persuasion and explanation why it’s so important. And „Let me take a look at this car“, „I have a mission“ (and brings me something from the other room). I don’t know why he’s so formal. 😄 So animation can teach a lot!